Now
Overcast
33°
High
32°
Low
21°

Blue-collar jobs seeking younger workers

Text Size: 
Tools Sponsor

BY ANTON TROIANOVSKI / The Wall Street Journal

Wednesday, Aug 20, 2008 - 01:06:31 am CDT



Even as the economy slumps and unemployment rises, strong demand for power plants, oil refineries and export goods has many manufacturers and construction contractors scrambling to find enough skilled workers.

With the shortage of welders, pipe fitters and other high-demand workers likely to get worse as more of them reach retirement age, unions, construction contractors and other businesses are trying to figure out how to attract more young people to those fields.

Story Photo
Mike Rowe, host of the Discovery Channel show "Dirty Jobs," stands next to venting gas on torch bottles at Cash's Scrap Metal in St. Louis. Rowe has worked with a company that makes construction equipment to help it recruit young workers as the company’s current work force ages. (Courtesy of Discovery Channel)
Some numbers

Skilled-labor shortages are likely to intensify in coming years as more workers retire and the economy picks up again. By 2012, predicts construction-industry consulting and investment banking firm FMI Corp., nationwide demand for electricians, masons and pipe fitters, if their numbers remain constant, will exceed supply by at least 5 percent. Regional and seasonal shortages are expected to be much steeper.

Their challenge: overcoming the perception that blue-collar trades offer less status, money and chance for advancement than white-collar jobs, and that college is the best investment for everyone.

To highlight the benefits of a career in the skilled trades, unions and employers are turning to schools, the military, MySpace and even a 46-year-old former opera singer named Mike Rowe.

Rowe is the host of the Discovery Channel series “Dirty Jobs,” which chronicles him tackling tasks ranging from alpaca shearing to steelworking. Rowe is in talks with Terex Corp., a maker of construction equipment, which has a two-year backlog of crane orders, thanks to strong overseas sales. Terex, which hired Rowe to appear at a trade show earlier this year, is hoping he can help it recruit young workers as the company’s current work force ages.

“Attracting the best and brightest into the industry is a challenge; it’s not happening,” says Mike Bazinet, a spokesman for the company.

Rowe confirmed he is talking to Terex, but doesn’t know what his specific role would be. It would likely involve extolling the virtues of manual labor, as he has done on his show since its debut three years ago.

“We’ve made work the enemy,” Rowe says. “Essentially we took the nobility and the necessity out of it and replaced it with this vague sense of drudgery.”

Rowe has also spoken to employees of W.W. Grainger Inc., an industrial-supplies distributor. Jim Ryan, the chief executive of Grainger, says his company has no immediate plans to team up with Rowe, but that it has spent about $400,000 over the past two years to fund technical-education programs around the country.

“In the last several years ... all of the benefits of a career in the trades have kind of gotten lost in the clutter of all the other career opportunities,” Ryan said. “What the industry needs is to be much more aggressive in marketing and creating visibility.”

Companies and unions don’t dispute that college can be a wise investment, but they also say some unionized craft workers can earn more than the average college graduate, without the burden of student debt.

“You earn while you learn,” says Brian Couch, a young electrician, in a video posted on the Web sites YouTube and MySpace. “It’s not like going to college where you go to school for five to eight years and have to work a part-time job.”

That video and several others like it were developed by public-relations firm Pac/West Communications for Local 48 of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers and the National Electrical Contractors Association in Portland, Ore.

The two groups have teamed up for the online campaign to encourage high-school graduates to consider an apprenticeship as an alternative to college.

In many parts of the economy, there are too many workers, rather than too few. Since January, the U.S. has lost 463,000 jobs. Residential construction and manufacturers that rely primarily on the U.S. market have been hit especially hard.

But the energy industry is hard up for workers who, among other things, can make precision welds, fit pipes for pipelines and oil refineries, and understand the complex electrical wiring in modern power plants. Though the weak housing market has idled many workers who did similar jobs for home builders, their skills often aren’t sharp enough to make the cut.

Dusty Henry, a 25-year-old electrician in Portland, Ore., who belongs to IBEW Local 48, says he earns $34 an hour working on renewable-energy projects while some of his friends who went to college are having a hard time finding jobs.

“I chose the path that I wanted to take...and learned as much as I could for that one thing,” Henry said. “You go to college to kind of figure out what you want to do, but if you don’t figure it out, you go out with debt and you still don’t know.”


$1 Sunday Delivery - Subscribe Today!
402 > Back to Top of Story

All posts to JournalStar.com are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
(optional)
   
whatever wrote on August 20, 2008 6:12 am:
" Generation upon generation of Americans have been taught that the trades are "beneath" them. It was implicit in my high school education that to pursue a trade was a path the "less desirable" elements of society pursued and "upstanding citizens" would only consider a college education which would guarentee a high paying job and a carefree lifetime. Turning this around in short order won't be easy. Relying on immigrants to fill the jobs isn't a solution either as many of these jobs require a decent education and absolute command of the English language. If anything this acute labor shortage will hamper economic growth in this country for several decades. "

Mike in DC wrote on August 20, 2008 8:03 am:
" Do the math. One can work full time while someone spends four to six or more years in college. Typically, that would leave them with 10's of thousands of student loans, and they can't retire until in their 60's. Tradesman or military guy retires in his late 40's and does something else for awhile. Sure, it may be dirty, and you may get less vacation, but being able to retire and do something else that early is only a dream for most white-collar workers. But, everyone thinks they are the next dude to invent or manage the next big thing and jet set all over the place and spend Friday afternoon trying to decide from the Mountain villa or the beach house to spend the weekend at. On the coasts, meanwhile, barely-legal immigrants own houses, massive new pickups (even with the gas prices) and can still afford dozens of rug-rats that white collar folk can't seem to hack. The reality is, most of the great minds, and many people in general learn from doing and being, and take only a few things from structured education. Demand will draw in supply; unless of course, we allow illegal immigrants and those that utilize them to distrort the price structure. But, in the next 10 years, you'll see people in the technology valleys get very very very rich. Robots. And they'll be doing things you'll say RIGHT NOW that robots can never do. "

Miles wrote on August 20, 2008 9:45 am:
" Why do physical labor when I can sit in a cushy office all day and blog on the LJS website? Yes, you can make a decent living with a blue collar job, but you are not flexible. If you are an electrician, that is all you can be. College degrees open up more possibilities. I'd rather use my head than my hands. "

Mr. Goodsense wrote on August 20, 2008 9:46 am:
" Reform welfare. Cut social programs. Do that, and I promise you that this shortage will remedy itself in a few years. So will the illegal immigration crisis. "

Lindsay wrote on August 20, 2008 10:03 am:
" I think as tuitions continue to skyrocket these types of careers will become more and more desireable to pursue. "

Nina wrote on August 20, 2008 10:04 am:
" These professions are needed, and Nebraska falls behind neighbors Co, Mo, Ia, and Ks in pay for blue-collar jobs. FAR behind in construction, for instance. The young are needed to carry on the professions, but for the present, 'young' may be over-rated. For instance, my husband, age 67, is the grain elevator manager. When something goes wrong with the auger apparatus, etc. which is about 60 feet up, all the younger employees have excuses that run from fear of heights to a bad knee. So guess who climbs the 60 ft. ladder to fix it? The senior citizen of the bunch, of course. You go, senior workers! "

Not So wrote on August 20, 2008 10:24 am:
" To Miles: You wrote that "College degrees open up more possibilities" this is not always the case. I know a lot of people who have college dgrees ranging from an Associates to a masters even a Doctorate, yet they don't have the options that most tradesmen have. here's a bit of wisdom that my grandfather shared with me years ago: "Learn a trade and don't be afraid to get your hands dirty because you never know when that knowledge will be required." I'm glad that I've learned the trade skills that i have, and even though I have a degree, it doesn't make me more marketable. what does, however, are the skills and the work ethic that i have developed over the years. "Give a man a fish and he eats for a day...Teach a man to fish and he eats for a lifetime!" Sometimes you just have to get your hands dirty. I wish the kids today would learn that instead of sitting around playing video games. "

Matt wrote on August 20, 2008 12:22 pm:
" I would love to work this kind of job. I work in an office currently and hate every minute of it. The problem is, being 18, with no training or experience in these fields, I get no chances of going into them. All the places around here look for people who have experience, and know what they are doing. If they would teach someone how to do it, they would have a much better chance at the younger generation coming their way. Not to mention the fact that you won't get paid nearly as much as an office job. If I could find a construction job that will pay me as much as I would make in an office job, I would be all over it. "

Its all about attitude wrote on August 20, 2008 12:27 pm:
" It doesn't really matter if you have a high-school, 2-year deg, 4-year deg, etc. A significant key to being successful is being WILLING to work, whether its in the dirt or at the desk. Ambition, drive, ingenuity, are critical for success and/or advancement no matter what the collar color. There are rare exceptions (good ol' boy network, got my job/degree from daddy) but its hard to argue the benefits of these core virtues.
Staying strong in the skilled trades is critical to this country. Its what keeps us independent and from sliding down the slippery slope of operating as a 'service provider' and importing the majority of our goods. Imagine if we were held hostage to foreign prices and quality we couldn't control for EVERYTHING we purchased!
No one should be afraid of going into these fields as long as they do it for the right reasons. There will always be a demand. Demonstrate the qualities above and a smart organization would have a hard time letting you go even if times get bad. These are valuable qualities to posess. "

Marge wrote on August 20, 2008 3:10 pm:
" Here's a thought: Reach out to women. They are often pushed away from trades because it's not 'ladylike'. Those who try find themselves up against sexual biases and harassment. Find ways to welcome women to the blue-collar workforce, and it will be easier. "