Joe Duggan: Serious about carp
The high esteem Europeans reserve for common carp has been well-documented.
In the old countries, some anglers pay for the right to catch carp from carefully managed private lakes. And while carp are considered a delicacy by many, true “carpophiles” release their catches so they can grow and fight again.
But this sure isn’t Europe.
Related Media
How to de-fin, skin and score a carp

Stan Krause demonstrates how to de-fin, skin and score a carp.Viewer advisory: Contains unsanitized images of fish cleaning. (Joe Duggan and Anthony R...
Keeping it simple is one of the appeals of carp fishing. Sometimes, using a deep-set bobber can be effective, but most carp anglers bottom fish because that’s where carp feed.
If you’re a beginning angler, go ahead and use heavier line, rods and reels, but as you gain experience, you’ll have a lot more fun catching carp on light tackle.
Use a 4/0 hook and experiment with bigger and smaller ones to see what works best. Turpin frequently uses a series of three split shots on the line, with the first one about a foot above the hook and the next two spaced evenly.
Krause prefers threading an egg sinker on the line before tying on a barrel swivel. Then tie a leader to the second eye of the swivel. He prefers using about 20-pound test braid for the leader to stand up to a carp’s penchant for dragging the line against rocks and brush.
Sweet corn is the universal bait; thread several kernels on a hook. Lots of dough ball recipes are available on the Internet. Some anglers smear a little peanut butter on their bait, too.
As for a location, just make sure to find a lake with plenty of carp, not much of a problem in Southeast Nebraska. Carp are perfect for bank anglers. Target points, bays, backwaters or the shallow water to the sides of dams. Try assorted depths, including very shallow, until you find them.
It’s legal to chum water for carp in Nebraska, and sweet corn does the trick, but don’t throw out so much that you fill them up before they find your bait.
Cleaning tips
The goal is to remove the all fins, the skin and score the meat. You’ll need a sharp fillet knife and pliers.
Start by locating the hump on the carp’s back, which is behind the head but in front of the dorsal fin. Slice away a piece of the hump, which will leave a small gouge in the fish. Insert the knife into the gouge so it’s parallel to the dorsal fin and run the blade at a shallow depth along one side of the dorsal fin all the way to the tail. Make the exact cut on the other side of the dorsal then use the pliers to remove the fin.
Turn the fish upside down and make a sideways slice underneath the pelvic fins, running to the vent. This cut should remove both the fins and vent. Then make shallow lateral cuts along both sides of the anal fin, to the tail, and remove the anal fin with the pliers.
Now grasp a corner of the skin in one hand and use the other hand to carefully separate the skin from the meat. Repeat the procedure for the other side.
Now gut the fish and thoroughly clean the cavity. Make the final cuts on both sides of the fish behind the head, all the way to the spine. Break the spine and pull the head off. Cut off the tail, using a game shears if you like.
After rinsing the meat in cold water, score the fish, starting on the tail end. Make a series of lateral incisions spaced about a quarter-inch apart, deep enough to cut through the small bones. When you reach the rib cage, make your cuts along the back meat only; it is not necessary to score the rib meat. Flip the fish over and score the other side.
Cooking carp
Frying: Cut the meat into chunks. Seasoned bread crumbs, flour or corn meal all work, but make sure you work the breading into the score cuts to draw in the hot oil, which will soften the small bones.
Smoking: The fish must be brined first. Krause likes to add Tender Quick cure to water in a 5-gallon bucket. Add the whole carp. Brine 12 to 24 hours, depending upon size of fish. Smoke until done (time will depend on your smoker and size of fish). Krause likes to start with hickory and finish with apple or cherry wood.
Strawberry dough ball
(Recipe from Rudy Chambers of Lincoln.)
In a large bowl, combine a cup of flour, a cup of corn meal and a package of strawberry gelatin (use sweetened gelatin, not sugar-free). Mix well. Gradually add white corn syrup until the meal attains a consistency that’s easy to form into balls that will hold their shape.
In Nebraska, we fail to understand an affinity for a fish we call rough. Then again, most of us don’t get British sitcoms or French arrogance, either.
Put simply, most Nebraska anglers wish common carp were far less common.
We covet walleye and will stay up all night to catch catfish. We’ll make it a life-goal to land (and release) an 8-pound largemouth, post photos of our biggest wipers on Internet forums and apply artistic license to tales of how many crappies we caught on consecutive casts that time they were really hitting.
But quiz anglers for a two-word synonym for “carp” and you’ll most likely hear, “trash fish.”
Tell someone you’re fishing for carp and you’ll get a look of pity or puzzlement. Release a foul-hooked carp in Nebraska at the risk of being dope-slapped. On the other hand, show up at the fish cleaning station with a stringer full, and the guys gutting their walleyes might point and whisper.
Several years ago, the Nebraska Game and Parks Commission launched Carp-O-Rama, essentially an attempt to make lemonade from the lemons swimming in Salt Valley lakes. The free, annual event teaches people how to catch carp. More importantly, it also teaches carp cleaning and preparation for the table.
The events have annually drawn crowds numbering well over 100, which indicate carp do indeed have a following in Nebraska.
If the crowd were a club, Stanley Krause, Richard Turpin and John Cariotto would proudly carry cards. Turpin and Krause have both helped out with Carp-O-Rama and are unapologetic carp apologists.
Try to consider their reasons objectively.
For starters, carp can be a challenge to catch. Many anglers mistakenly think carp fishing requires little skill.
Turpin put it this way: Catching fish such as bass and walleye generally is a function of finding them. Once you do, landing them often can be simple.
Conversely, finding carp is relatively easy, considering their abundance. Sometimes, carp bite aggressively. But sometimes, for reasons that are hard to tell, carp won’t bite at all. And sometimes, they’ll bite (or suck) so delicately, they’ll keep cleaning the hook until they swim off with their fill.
Krause loves the fighting ability of a carp, especially on light tackle. They’ll pull drag, wear out forearms and truly test an angler’s ability.
They’ve got more carp praises.
For example, the best bait for carp doesn’t squiggle, stink, leave dirt under your fingernails or cost a lot. If you are what you eat, carp are as clean as an ear of sweet corn.
Turpin once caught a bunch of carp from the Missouri River by slipping a hook in wadded pieces of cinnamon roll left over from breakfast.
Finally, as Cariotto, Krause and Turpin all insist, carp are perfectly good eats. Yes, they’ve got more bones than a cemetery. But learn a few techniques that help minimize the bones and you’ll find carp taste good fried, smoked, canned or even chowdered.
And hey, for those of you who have never caught a fish you could release, carp are perfect. Keep your limit, please. Wait a minute, there is no limit.
Just imagine a day in Nebraska when we keep and eat every carp we catch.
No, we won’t be Europeans, ’cause our sitcoms will still be funny.
Reach Joe Duggan at 473-7239 or jduggan@journalstar.com.

Facebook
del.icio.us
Fark It
Reddit





Post Your Comment
Standards and RulesYour posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
Old Pickles Employee wrote on July 20, 2008 12:50 pm:
Dave wrote on July 20, 2008 3:36 pm:
Phil wrote on August 3, 2008 2:40 pm:
Instead of using 4/0 try 4,6,or 8 hooks with a hair rig, we only want carp not sharks, and use lighter line where there are no snags.
I would be most grateful if you could put me in touch with the gentlmen you spoke of in the article.
Yours gratefully,
A European. "