Now
A Few Clouds
68°
High
79°
Low
58°

Supreme Court claims jurisdiction over Canadian father

Text Size: 
Tools Sponsor

By OSKAR GARCIA / The Associated Press

Friday, Dec 14, 2007 - 05:50:12 pm CST

OMAHA — The Nebraska Supreme Court on Friday said the state has jurisdiction over the Canadian father of a Nebraska girl, allowing him to face a lawsuit in the United States for a sexual assault that allegedly happened in Canada.

The sexual molestation allegations made in the cross-country child-custody case persuaded the Nebraska Legislature to take a rare step earlier this year and extend the reach of Nebraska’s courts.

The Nebraska Supreme Court said in its opinion that it’s in the interest of the 9-year-old girl that the case be handled in Nebraska rather than Canada. The judges said it was reasonable for the father to face civil action here.

The ruling overturned a Lancaster County District Court decision.

Richard Ducote, a New Orleans-based lawyer representing the girl and her mother in the case, said the ruling means the girl can file a civil lawsuit against her father in Nebraska.

A lawyer for the father did not return a phone call by The Associated Press seeking comment on Friday.

A psychiatrist reported to police in Nebraska that the Canadian-born girl may have been sexually abused by her father while visiting him in Canada under a court-mandated visitation. The psychiatrist reached that conclusion after meeting with the girl, whose residence is in Nebraska.

The father denied the allegations through his attorney, and an investigation by Canadian police did not lead to charges against him.

But a Nebraska judge believed there was enough evidence to issue an order to temporarily keep the girl, then 8, from having to return to her father for visits and request that Nebraska courts have jurisdiction over the case.

Gaining control of the case was impossible because of a decade-old law in 45 states that guides child-custody cases involving other states and countries.

The girl returned to Canada few times since then, and suffered more sexual abuse, according to her mother.

The law, called the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act, gives foreign courts that make original child-custody decisions powers that are equal to those held by their U.S. counterparts, even when the children live in the United States. The shared law is designed to prevent parents from seeking and getting different custody decisions in other states or countries.

A Canadian court in 2000 made the original custody decision in the case of the 8-year-old Nebraska girl.

Alarmed by the story, the Nebraska Legislature quickly passed a bill earlier this year that does not nix the uniform child custody law it shares with other states, but allows Nebraska courts to trump their foreign counterparts in cases of alleged abuse involving children who live in the state.


$1 Sunday Delivery - Subscribe Today!
Nebraska > Back to Top of Story

All posts to JournalStar.com are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
(optional)
   
keith wrote on December 14, 2007 6:09 pm:
" All I read is a child beening used as a pawn. Canadian have not charged this man. This will lead to a federal court case. Nebraska law is over reaching for the federal court Another lost case, why because the mother is, or maybe seeking to harm this man for no reason except for hate "

David wrote on December 14, 2007 8:14 pm:
" I just hope this isn't abused by parents and they will truly take the best interests of the children. I can see false abuse claims in order to change jurisdiction. "

Disagree wrote on December 14, 2007 11:12 pm:
" I disagree with this ruling. The Canadian police found nothing to charge the father with. Were it a country without strong, fair laws, I could see it. But Canada has a good legal system and is not known for corruption or ill treatment based on such things as gender. "

Charlie wrote on December 15, 2007 8:30 am:
" I trust the courts of Nebraska to fairly decide justice than I do any foreign court, whether it is Iran or North Korea or even Canada! The new law is a victory for Nebraskan. Let Nebraska courts decide justice for Nebraska residents. "

db wrote on December 15, 2007 4:05 pm:
" Charlie, they were Canadian residents for the original order of custody. The alleged conduct happened in Canada. Basically, this makes a parent have to travel hundreds if not thousands of miles due to another parent's allegations of something that actually happened where the charged parent lives. The UCCJEA is important so one parent is not essentially taken out of a child's life by the custodial parent moving away. "