Now
Fair
31°
High
34°
Low
11°

Emerald ash borer could destroy over 2 million trees

Text Size: 
Tools Sponsor

By ALGIS LAUKAITIS / Lincoln Journal Star

Monday, Nov 26, 2007 - 12:13:52 am CST



The emerald ash borer is a  metallic green bug with a voracious appetite for healthy ash trees.

The insect, commonly called EAB, already has killed more than 25 million trees in Michigan, Illinois, Ohio, Indiana, Pennsylvania, Maryland, West Virginia and Ontario, Canada.

Story Photo
Adult emerald ash borers emerge from an infested ash tree (Fraxinus pennsylvanica). (Deborah Miller)
Is it emerald ash borer?



Some Nebraskans have already lost trees to what they thought was emerald ash borer.

"There already have been some trees taken down by mistake in Nebraska because the homeowners were told their trees had emerald ash borer," said Mark Harrell, Nebraska Forest Service Forest Health program leader.

"None of these trees were infested. If homeowners are told they have emerald ash borer, they may want to contact another certified arborist or other tree care professional to get a second opinion," Harrell wrote in a news release.

Experts from the state Forest Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, and Nebraska Department of Agriculture are trained to recognize emerald ash borer, or EAB, and can determine whether the insect is present.

Because EAB only attacks ash trees, a person should be sure the tree in question is an ash and not a similar-looking species.

If a tree is infested with EAB, it must be removed to help prevent the insect from spreading.

In urban areas, trees may be near utility lines, homes or other buildings, so it is often best to have the tree removed by a certified arborist.

Reputable arborists will be able to provide proof of insurance and references, as well as written documentation of the work to be done.



Emerald ash borer

What is it? A metallic green insect with a flat back that attacks only ash trees. Adults are about a half-inch long.

How did it get here? Scientists believe the insect came to the U.S. from its native Asia in wood packing material aboard a cargo ship or airplane.

Where is it found? The emerald ash borer has been detected in Michigan, Indiana, Ohio, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Maryland, West Virginia and Ontario, Canada, making it a national pest problem.

How many trees has it killed? More than 25 million so far.

Is it in Nebraska? No emerald ash borers have been detected in the state. Officials cannot predict if or when the insect will appear here.

What are some EAB symptoms on ash trees? They include winding tunnels under the bark, D-shaped exit holes on the trunk, as well as canopy loss, usually from the top down. Other symptoms include vertical splitting in the bark and increased woodpecker activity.

Who do I call if I think my tree has EAB? Call the city forester's office at 441-7036 or the Nebraska Forest Service office in Lincoln at 472-2944.

Where can I get more information? www.nfs.unl.edur www.emeraldashborer.info

And federal, state and local forestry officials fear it will make its way to Nebraska and other Great Plain states.

“It may already be here,” said  City Forester Steve Schwab.

The  emerald ash borer was first detected in southeast Michigan in 2002, Schwab said, and scientists discovered it had been in the state for eight years.

If and when EAB comes to Nebraska, officials say, the state could lose an estimated 2.2 million ash trees.

The cost to remove and replace these trees could exceed more than $1.5 billion. It also could result in the loss of what trees do: provide shade, filter air and water and protect streets and highways.

“It will be similar to Dutch elm disease in the 1960s, which rapidly killed millions of trees in Nebraska and dramatically converted lush urban forests to barren, shadeless urban landscapes,” State Forester Scott Josiah said in a news release.

Lincoln could lose between 100,000 and 120,000 ash trees, Schwab said — 25 percent to 30 percent of the city’s trees.

City Parks and Recreation Director Lynn Johnson recently told Mayor Chris Beutler it would cost about $38 million to remove and replace 30,000 ash trees on city property.

Bug hitches rides

Experts believe the Emerald ash borer, which is native to Asia, arrived in the U.S. in wood packing material carried in a cargo ship or airplane.

Adult insects nibble on ash foliage but cause little damage, foresters say.

However, the larvae feed on the inner bark of ash trees, disrupting the trees’ ability to transport water and other nutrients. The exotic insect only attacks ash trees.

There are no effective measures to prevent the spread of the borer, said Steve Rasmussen, a district forester with the Nebraska Forest Service, based in Wayne.

“It isn’t selective. It kills all ages, all sizes, and all species of ash trees,”  Rasmussen said.

Green ash trees are the only ones native to Nebraska. But other species — like white, black and purple ash — have been planted in the state. Foresters say all ash tree species are at risk.

The good news? The insect only moves about a half-mile to 2 miles a year on its own, Rasmussen said.

The bad news? The insect can “leap frog” large areas by catching rides in firewood and wood products.

Firewood inspections

Quarantines are in place in many states to prevent infested ash firewood, logs or nursery trees from being transported and starting new infestations. Violations could result in fines.

Nebraska has no restrictions, but officials are asking people to not haul ash firewood, especially if you go camping or deer hunting.

Last year, the state Department of Agriculture began to randomly inspect firewood across Nebraska, said state entomologist Julie Van Meter, and has found no evidence of EAB.

Staffers inspect wood at gas stations, groceries, nurseries and other outlets, she said. Her five-person staff looks for not only EAB but also for other pests and diseases.

“Firewood is a big issue. It gets us out there looking at what is coming in and seeing it,” Van Meter said. “We’re happy to see a lot of firewood is of Nebraska origin. But there is a lot of firewood coming in.”

More than a year ago, the state formed the Emerald Ash Borer Working Group. The group, made up of federal, state and local officials, is looking at ways to prevent EAB from entering the state and strategies to deal with it if it arrives.

Nebraska was the first state to require origin labeling on nursery stock, Van Meter said, two years before Michigan detected EAB.

Under the program, the state’s 1,100 licensed  nursery dealers and growers  are required to code tree stock and provide annual lists of their tree providers.

States team up

Foresters are asking people to plant species other than ash. The goal: Create diversity, so if the borer arrives, damage would be less.

Spraying ash trees won’t do any good because there is no evidence the insect is here, Rasmussen said.

“Our hope is before it gets across the Midwest, we find ways to stop it,” Rasmussen said.

Injections for ash trees are available to combat EAB, Van Meter said,  but they must be done every year and could get expensive. And there are no guarantees it will stop EAB from killing a tree.

Researchers are looking at control methods, including insecticides and parasitic wasps. Meanwhile, they’re trying to raise awareness about the potential threat, which has become a national problem.

With the help of a $1 million grant from the U.S. Forest Service, the Nebraska Forest Service, in partnership with forestry agencies in Kansas, South Dakota and North Dakota,  are working on an initiative to prepare for the insect’s arrival.

All four states plan to survey ash tree resources, including locations and condition of trees. They also will distribute more information.

Finally, they plan to find uses for the millions of ash trees that may have to be cut down. Burning the trees as biomass  to produce energy is one possibility.

Reach Algis J. Laukaitis at 402-473-7243 or alaukaitis@journalstar.com.



$1 Sunday Delivery - Subscribe Today!
Local > Back to Top of Story

All posts to JournalStar.com are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
(optional)
   
Doug wrote on November 26, 2007 4:42 am:
" A very interesting story related to global commerce. I believe it will be just a matter of time before it is a human disease that can not be stopped, much like imported disease killed many Native Americans. "

Oh that's nice wrote on November 26, 2007 5:18 am:
" That is really nice, now the Parks and Rec manager sees a problem with trees and wants more money that way, guess what, I don't think so. Please control spending and find ways to do things that don't cost so much. "

WCG wrote on November 26, 2007 6:48 am:
" This is why the whole idea of 'approved street trees' is so wrong-headed. We need to be planting a huge variety of trees, and not all on the same block, either. Instead of requiring that a certain tree be planted on each block, the city should simply have a list of tree species that are banned from being planted alongside the street - and this list should be as short as possible. That way, when one of these disasters occur, we won't lose every tree on the block,... and 30 percent of the trees citywide. Diversity is the key. "

Put the brakes on this one . . . wrote on November 26, 2007 8:14 am:
" Also, I could get cancer, or get hit by a car today. Let's not over-hype something that may or may not happen. Trees can be replaced. We are talking about the giant redwoods or 200 year old oaks . . . "

Don't Live In Fear wrote on November 26, 2007 8:48 am:
" Dutch Elm Disease, Tip Blight, Emerald Ash borer - the list will continue as long as there is life on this planet. We should not refuse to plant a species of tree because of fear of disease. If that was the case we shouldn't plant any trees. While diversity is important to tree planting other things need to be considered including continuity, design, pattern, etc. A hodge podge of trees is not the answer . . . "

On the other hand.... wrote on November 26, 2007 9:32 am:
" when we (the citizenry) DON'T get this kind of advanced warning, everyone is up in arms because "someone should have seen this coming" and planned accordingly. SO... for those that are complaining already about what this might cost you, remember, you can't have it both ways folks. Either you want to know what could be coming down the pike, or you want to be surprised as all get out when the city arborists come and cut down all your shade trees. You choose. And to WCG... Right On! "

Jay wrote on November 26, 2007 9:35 am:
" I hope the City and developers stop planting ash now. Even as late as last year an ash was removed by my house and then the city came back in a planted another ash. Kiss your ash goodbye and stop planting these! Sure EAB might not get here for a decade or more, but a newly planted tree wont start to produce real benefits for 20 - 30 years. Tossing money down the drain if planting ash. Can the city say diversity? "

Gildersleeve wrote on November 26, 2007 9:38 am:
" Control spending? The Parks & Rec Dept. has already made drastic cuts (including eliminating some youth programs) because every time the city needs to make budget cuts, guess who loses the most? Maybe the city should just save time and shut down Parks & Rec altogether! It seems headed that way! "

Ks wrote on November 26, 2007 10:59 am:
" Guess Id better sharpen my cleats and tune up the chipper.Lincoln will be handing out $$$ left and right to remove these trees!Bring 'em on. "

Andy wrote on November 26, 2007 11:06 am:
" So if this EAB is going to be such a costly problem for elected officials and homwowners alike, no control options avaiable, why then are nurseries still selling ash trees? I also see that some nurseries doing work on city property are also continuing to plant ash - WHY? To knowingly continue to sell and use this tree with the problems at hand is a disservice to the industry and the public. You should feel terrible. "

CM wrote on November 26, 2007 11:29 am:
" "...do things that don't cost so much?" So we should wait till we have a bunch of widow makers over heads before we decide to spend some money? "

Becky wrote on November 26, 2007 1:47 pm:
" If this is going to be as bad as everyone says how are we going to pay for it as a community? Last I read the parks dept was already cutting programs and staff. Is there a plan in place, will the tree be replaced and are we a little bit wiser now since we have learned this lesson on diversity twice now? I hope so. If this bugger can spread across 8 states in 5 years I would guess it will be in NE soon?! Lets see a plan in place with community involvement soon!a "

Irresponsible wrote on November 26, 2007 2:02 pm:
" The quote the city arborist says "it may already be here" is irresponsible. It is part of the typical city knee-jerk reaction to anything and everything. There has been no known discovery or damage done by the emerald ash borer. That doesn't mean we should ignore the potential risks but to discuss removal of ash trees at this time is premature and complete nonsense. Please do further research on emerald ash borer fraud where communities have been encouraged by the lumber industry to have trees cut down for free . . . guess whom benefits here. "

Annie wrote on November 26, 2007 10:52 pm:
" I think these are all very interesting comments and observations. . . and even some predictions! Regardless of this bug or the next invasive critter I for one am tired of linden trees, honeylocust, pear, and ash to say the least (seen one ash you have seen 'em all) – lets plants some diversity and improve the health of this treemendous resource! And to the city arborist, way to go out on the proverbial limb - I hope you are wrong but it would seem after reading what the university of google has to say I am thinking it is a real concern very very soon. May the forest be with you! "

Common Sense wrote on November 26, 2007 10:56 pm:
" @ Irresponsible: I am not sure where you are coming from…“ There has been no known discovery or damage done by the emerald ash borer. That doesn't mean we should ignore the potential risks but to discuss removal of ash trees at this time is premature and complete nonsense.” Do you mean “no known discovery or damage” by the insect here in Nebraska…or anywhere? Surely you are not denying a potential problem exists. I suggest that not discussing removal of infected trees is being irresponsible. Unless suddenly we all have deep pockets and can afford not to plan for an inevitable future expense. Starting in two locations this insect has spread across 8 states and Canada, causing the loss of 25 - 30 millions trees at a cost measured in the tens of millions of dollars. And you think the city arborist is jumping the gun? The dollars spent on research / eradication (tens of millions, and really nobody really knows how really high this # actually is) while making some progress, has not resulted in ANY successful control measures to date. The most fiscally responsible and conservative approach to this inevitable insect problem is through community education, outreach, planting for diversity. "

Robert Smith wrote on November 26, 2007 11:33 pm:
" I'm an arborist and I work for the Arbor Day Foundation. I've spoken with city foresters and other arborists in Michigan, Ohio, Indiana, and Illinois and other areas where emerald ash borer has already been found. These experienced individuals each separately told me gypsy moth and Dutch elm disease don't even compare to the impact that emerald ash borer has had on their communities. All it would take is one I-80 traveler driving west with a load of infested firewood headed to one of our campgrounds. This pest is coming fast. It would be wise to start planting a wide diversity of trees starting now. "

mike wrote on November 27, 2007 3:42 am:
" if everyone would buy and plant a tree of there own then the city would not have to spend the money that dont have "

Jen wrote on November 27, 2007 7:27 am:
" One word: nature. "

amazed wrote on November 27, 2007 8:02 am:
" I am amazed that a problem is dealt with in an emotional manner and not too bright at that. We have three major tree blights on our hands; Dutch Elm disease (elms), Brown wilt (Scotch pine) and now ash trees are at risk. There are hundreds of different types of trees to plant. Ash is cheap and easy to plant and a rapid grower. What a loss. There are some beautiful white ashes in southeast Nebraska that are over hundreds years old. "

What wrote on November 27, 2007 12:21 pm:
" What do the staffers do where an inspection of wood at gas stations, groceries, nurseries and other outlets turns up EAB or other pests and diseases. Remove it? Fine them? Sound the alarm? What? My entire neighborhood streets are lined with ash 40 to 50 years old. It will look a disaster afterwards. "

Chip Doolittle wrote on November 27, 2007 3:22 pm:
" I hate to say this but the sky is not falling in. There are treatments available and they are very reasonable and they can last for 2 years. It's not like a Dutch Elm disease prevention treatment, which is expensive, or Pine Wilt treatments which can also be expensive. Our company has been very successful in Michigan with treatments and have about a 95% success ratio. But there are several solutions to this problem, so don't go out and cut down the tree that Grandmother planted! "