Now
Fair with Haze
74°
High
82°
Low
63°

Letters, 11/26: The price of arrogance

Text Size: 
Tools Sponsor

Sunday, Nov 26, 2006 - 12:13:59 am CST

Roger Conrad’s partisan screed (Column, Nov. 18) is just another predictable bleat in the Bush administration’s deceptive and tedious chorus of “us and them,” “for us or against us.”

The midterm elections were not a paean to Democrats.They were an overdue rebuke of this administration’s sanctimony. Voters rebuffed being preached to by those who persist in their narrow view of history and who demonstrate the intellectual depth of a Petri dish.

A book I read recently recounted how the administration’s myopia led to the invasion of Iraq:

* We misjudged and exaggerated the dangers to the U.S.

* Our misjudgments reflected our profound ignorance of the history of the people in the area.

* We do not have the God-given right to shape every nation in our own image.

* We failed to retain support because we did not explain fully what was happening and why we were doing what we did.

* We failed the task of winning hearts and minds of people from a totally different culture.

* We failed to analyze and debate our actions … and the necessity of changing course when failure was clear.

These quotes are from Robert McNamara, secretary of defense under Kennedy and Johnson, in his book, “In Retrospect — the Tragedy and Lessons of Vietnam.”

The voters took Bush and his lock step marionettes to the metaphorical woodshed for their deadly arrogance, inexcusable ignorance and provocative hectoring.

Larry McClung, Lincoln

Put raceway elsewhere

Greg Sanford already had a raceway. It was in Scribner. The Motorplex closed after he couldn’t obtain full funding for a paved road to the strip. In Scribner, the county agreed to pay half the cost of paving, but Sanford wanted almost full funding, then refused to make necessary improvements to his facility mandated by the National Hot Rod Association, and he abandoned the project. (The current area proposed for his facility is on an unpaved road.)

Judging from Sanford’s past business acumen, one has to wonder at a proposed facility of only 602 parking spaces and seating for 5,000 spectators. That’s 8.3 people per vehicle.

I admit, my hobby is not racing. My hobby happens to be enjoying country life in our beautiful rural setting mostly free from air and noise pollution. And raising my sons with the same quality of life that I experienced growing up here, as well as my father and my grandfather before that. The proposed facility is near Game and Parks land, which includes the Jack Sinn Memorial Wildlife Preserve. Bald eagles and other wildlife are home to this area. Why should our quality of life be compromised by a polluting, here-today-gone-tomorrow venture?

People supporting the drag strip say, “just move if you don’t like it.” This area is not just a few old farms — we are a thriving community of hundreds wanting to preserve our way of life; many of us have had this land in our families for nearly a century. This strip would be far worse for us than it would be for racers to drive a couple of hours to an existing strip.

There can be a compromise, but it needs to be on commercial land not already slated for agriculture, near paved roads, and with sound business backing.

Theresa Tvrdy, Ceresco

War is hell for all

The last time we heard the term, post-traumatic stress disorder, it was the 1970s and the Vietnam vets were suffering from it. The military is doing a good job this time taking care of the soldiers, sailors and Marines coming back from the sand box. They have a good system in place.

The problem is that there are hundreds of civilians in this war that have no system in place to deal with their problems. The contractors are forced to try to get treatment through insurance companies that fight them at every turn.

If you think that the contractors should just suffer, listen to this: “They see the same things our soldiers do: same trauma, same carnage, same wreckage. They face the same risk as our soldiers,” said Col. Kathy Platoni, a clinical psychologist who has traveled extensively throughout Iraq as the leader of a combat stress-control unit working on the battlefield.

I was one of these contractors; I wrote a letter previously to the Journal Star about recognition of the contractors’ contributions. This is another type of recognition. These people need help. They are government employees while in Iraq, they should not have to beg for their sanity when they come home.

Wallace McNabb, Lincoln  

Nebraska’s ugly side

Have to agree with Rosanne M. Peterson’s letter of Nov. 19. We have traveled a great deal in the last 10 years. We always know when we are back in Nebraska, no matter which road we bring into the state. It’s littered, weeds growing, dirty.

We have lived here our whole life, it is a shame that Nebraska does not take some pride in themselves. Even the home owners could do a lot to improve their homes along the roads, highways. What a shame.

Roberta Felker, McCook

Marine dishonored

The editorial staff of the Lincoln Journal Star should be ashamed of its representation Nov. 21 of the funeral of Marine Lance Cpl. Michael Scholl. Not only do they dishonor his branch of service by referring to him as a “soldier,” but they ignore the human interest story of those that came to honor him, referring to the Patriot Guard Riders as “a few dozen supporters.”

There were more than 85 members of that organization present for more than five hours, standing a vigil to honor this fallen hero. They came from as far away as Missouri, Kansas, Iowa, and South Dakota, even though some had never met or even heard the name of this Marine before. They did not need to know how beloved his parents are in their communities; they did not need any information other than the fact that he had paid the ultimate sacrifice for his country and was deserving of recognition, honor, and respect.

Other members of the group were personal friends of the family and would have preferred to be participating in the memorial service inside, yet saw their mission in participating in a show of support for the family, the flag and their country in defiance of the protesters across the street. The irony of this Marine’s death to uphold their ability to protest was ignored in the reports provided by the “news” paper.

The blatant inaccuracy and lack of respect in the paper’s reporting of the day’s events is a telling indictment of the Lincoln Journal Star’s lack of professionalism, disregard of the facts and inability to accurately report the news.

Herb Anderson, Lincoln


$1 Sunday Delivery - Subscribe Today!
Letters > Back to Top of Story

All posts to JournalStar.com are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
(optional)
   
dtw wrote on November 26, 2006 2:06 am:
" I always enjoy reading your pieces Larry. You actually have facts and commentary unlike the majority of "self-proclaimed political savy writers". "

OldVet wrote on November 26, 2006 4:54 am:
" Wallace, why don't you go see a psychologist who is trained in PTSD if you are having problems? Why should the government pay for your treatment. You were paid extremely well while you were over there as compared to the military and should be able to afford to pay for treatment. I'm not degrading what you did or what you went through, I'm just saying you shouldn't expect the government pay for treatment, the government did not order you to go, you went on your own accord. "

P. ROBERT wrote on November 26, 2006 6:53 am:
" Mr. Anderson, you don't have to look past the first letter to understand the Journal's bias. I keep hoping that now that the Dems control the Congress and Senate, they might be able to get back to reporting the news instead of campaigning for the left. "

OIF vet wrote on November 26, 2006 9:19 am:
" Wallace, I do feel for you, but i have to agree with OldVet. You were paid three times what most enlisted soldiers were paid. I admit, I chose to join the Army, I did not choose to go to Iraq. You chose to go to war. I do wish you the best and thank you for you service! "

Hank wrote on November 26, 2006 9:23 am:
" Mr. Anderson, by demanding an elaborate coverage of a military funeral, you are effectively asking the Journal Star to participate in the glorification of war. The newspaper should, and does, devote its efforts to reporting the news, which includes ample attention to our foreign policies, our conduct in war, and many other relevant issues. It sickens me that you and other Nebraskans are more concerned about describing a funeral than they are about how to prevent those funerals in the first place. The question is: Why did the soldier have to die? What on earth did he or she die for? Why do we continue to ask our soldiers to kill and get killed in Iraq? Those are the questions are want to see addressed in the Journal Star. Leave the funerals for the grieving families. Please stop using soldiers' funerals to glorify war and justify our shameful and destructive overseas aggression. "

Joe Facts wrote on November 26, 2006 9:50 am:
" Ms. Tvrdy, please get your facts before you form an opinion, this letter is based on hearsay. Were you at the Dodge county commissioner meetings or reseached the minutes of them? Do you even know where the proposed facility is in Lancaster County? You stated it is on a unpaved road?? My understanding is Hwy 77 is a paved 4 lane highway which is adjacent to the proposed race facility. Fact, all development land is Ag zoned and is changed to commercial for furthur development. This ground is 5 miles from the Lincoln city limits along a major 4 lane hwy that will be zoned commercial for future growth. Living within 5 miles of the city along a mojor 4 lane hwy is not rural. You say you dont like noise and enjoy rural life...rural life is noisey, it has 100 dB tractors pulling tillage equipment thru the fields, diesel engines with no mufflers pumping irrigation wells 24/7 thruout the summer, drying bins with 100 dB motors pulling air to dry the grain, are you against the noisey farmer too? Race cars in most all NHRA classes require mufflers that limit the cars to 95 dB, which is less than alot of farm equipment. Most all the cars that ran in street legal racing had mufflers. And I am not against the farmer, I farm as well, one final note, ag chemicals is more harsh on the wildlife than any racetrack will ever be. Eagles will not be killed. deer ran over, or pheasants maimed by racecars. Lets work together instead of the just me attitude, isnt this why we are Nebraskan's? "

Susana wrote on November 26, 2006 11:47 am:
" Wallace, I have compassion for you but no sympathy. Why are Americans doing the contracting work in Iraq? Shouldn't Halliburton/KBR hire Iraqis? Do you suppose that the unemployment rate in Iraq is feeding the frustration there and by extension the attacks on Americans? Larry, you nailed it. Great letter. "

Joe wrote on November 26, 2006 12:36 pm:
" "Hank" can you please tell us all what is the job of a combat soldier? I was in the army as a 13B MOS which is an artillaryman-military occupational skill for all you non-military people and when I joined the military in that job I knew fully well that I could be sent somewhere to either kill or be killed serving my country, whether I agreed with the policy or not, thats what a soldier does. "

NIMBY wrote on November 26, 2006 12:49 pm:
" Mrs. Tvrdy, thank you for your letter, but it screams loud and clear not in my backyard. All of the people who protested against Mr Sanford's soil mining permit used all these reasons including dump truck traffic, noise, dirt and mud on hwys and soil erosion to prevent further development in your backyard. You even created a website to help all people in Lancaster county for rural life to care for your special needs and rights to enjoy rural life. Where are all of you now in helping the people and neighbors protest the soil mining permit at Hwy 77 and Waverly Rd that was to be before the Lancaster County Board on November 21st to mine over million yards of soil on the approximately the same size site? There was no one there. Oh thats right, it wasnt in your backyard anymore, you only want to protect rural life in your nieghborhood. "

Herb Anderson wrote on November 26, 2006 1:14 pm:
" Hank: I am not demanding "elaborate coverage" of a funeral; I was only asking that the NEWS paper get their facts and references straight. Lance Corporal Scholl was a Marine, not a Soldier. He was a member of this community throughout his short life; his parents and step-parents are still members of our community. I am simply standing up for someone who stood for us. Further, attempting to promote your own agenda must be clouding your vision; if you look at the letter I wrote, you will see that I answer your question about why this young man paid the ultimate sacrifice; in order to give freedom to us all, including you as well as the protesters who showed up at the funeral. My letter in now way was an attempt to glorify war, it was calling the Journal Star to responsibility for the inaccuracy of their reporting. As to the rest of the claptrap in your letter, I do not find it worthy of taking any more of my time. If you want to promote your agenda, write your own letter to the editor instead of criticizing mine. I will continue to mourn and honor those who are injured or fall for our country, and I will show them my respect because it is the right thing to do. "

NHRAjeff wrote on November 26, 2006 1:26 pm:
" Theresa, Mr Sanford is spending countless hours and dollars to help our community build a facility that will generate tourism dollars to our state. Mr Sanford has demonstrated by small business awards and letters of recommendations from former governors and state senators that he has ran a successful race facility at the Nebraska Motorplex. Mr Sanford has realized as do many of the racers and race fans that the remote location in Scribner could not draw in the National Events and shows that would bring people to Nebraska. Building a facility in the Lincoln area with the necessary lodging and restuarants will not only bring people and large events to Nebraska but those people will bring hundreds of dollars to small businesses throughout Lincoln and most importantly these dollars will help the owners and employees of the these businesses support their kids and family. I ask what are you doing to create a business to help thousands of people in our community enjoy the good life of Nebraska? "

Aaron wrote on November 26, 2006 1:41 pm:
" Do you really believe that race cars are more quiet than a tractor. You can't hear a tractor a 1/4 mile away, but you can hear a car with glasspack mufflers or open exhaust. I am going to guess that you don't farm near a race track. I farm seven miles from Butler County Speedway near Rising City. I don't care to sit outside on Friday nights and listen to race cars go round and round for hours. So much for the peaceful country. "

Josh2 wrote on November 26, 2006 2:16 pm:
" P Robert - I fail to see how a letter to the editor on the opinion page represents any bias of the LJS or that a letter can be considered news. Maybe you should stick to Fox if you want 'reporting'. "

Zoomie wrote on November 26, 2006 2:53 pm:
" Reportedly, the VA has finished a study which estimates if the war in Iraq were winding down now, but with some American presence remaining in Iraq for at least a decade (and remember the Bush Admin has never answered exactly when they think we should leave, and have spent over $100 million building 10-12 massive, protected permanent military bases for long-term stays), that the projected cost over the next ten years will be $127 BILLION more than currently allocated to the VA for veteran care. And thats just active duty military/retirees. Meanwhile, the Bush Admin have -- more than in any war in America's history -- outsourced thousands of traditional military jobs to corporate America. And investigation after investigation by the Special IG for Iraqi Reconstruction have determined those companies are ripping off taxpayers to the tune of tens of billions of dollars while NOT fulfilling their cost-plus contracts (which explains why the GOP run Congress' last act pre-election was to dismantle the Special IG's entire office by next year). And none of this even touches on the damage, short and long term, being done to hundreds of thousands (perhaps millions) of Iraqis, adult and child. Is it any wonder a growing number of Iraqis blame their suffering and death on us? "

CS wrote on November 26, 2006 3:27 pm:
" I also question why contractors haul water, do laundry, move fuel, and other 'mundane' duties, when MOS's still exist and are staffed for those jobs regularly. Ft. Lee VA is full of AIT soldiers that are there for fabric repair, galley, Logistics and Supply, Petroleum and Water, and Mechanized Transport. Why are they only making E1-E4 pay when contractors are getting paid 80,000 a year? "

A few dozen? wrote on November 26, 2006 3:41 pm:
" Doesn't 85 = about 7 dozen? Is 7 "a few"? Maybe, maybe not. But it sure seems like Mr. Anderson is looking really, *really* hard for some bias in the LJS's report, for something to get indignant about. Newspapers reporters aren't military aficionados. As a reasonably educated person, I had no idea that mourning a fallen American and calling him a "soldier" when he served in the Marine Corps was an affront. Perhaps your indignance might be better spent on those who sent this young man to his death, rather than on the folks who report the tragedy. "

whatever wrote on November 26, 2006 3:57 pm:
" If you make a decision to take a high paying job in a war sector, then you should be adult enough to live with the consequences. If you need help, go find help. My grandparents went through World War I and the horrifying treatment of the "non-English", the farm crisis of the 1920's, The Great Depression, World War II, forced relocation for government projects and the list goes on and on. I don't think they ever asked for help. I don't think they were any different than anyone else of that generation. For a country that has accomplished so much in it's history have we really reached the point where no one assumes responsibility and expects someone else to pick up the tab? Are we really that hopeless and hapless that we just can't entertain the thought of helping ourselves? "

Sam B wrote on November 26, 2006 5:09 pm:
" An editorial page is for editorials, not reporting the news. It also has no bias, as the LJS supported Bush in 2004 (much to my dismay). I expect that the editorial page will remain the same now that the Democrats control both houses of Congress. It's too bad some people are too ignorant to distinguish the difference between news reporting and editorial writing. I should have thought that calling the editorial page by its given name would have provided a much needed clue to people like "P ROBERT". "

Not so Rural wrote on November 26, 2006 6:57 pm:
" Mrs. Tvrdy needs a wake up call. The land all along Highway 77 will become commercial in the coming years. It is close to the best interstate interchange along the north side of Lincoln. I don't think the people of Lincoln and Lancaster county agree with her wishes to limit the growth and opportunities to our county. The site for the race track is on a PAVED 4-LANE highway, only a few miles from the interstate. It is a good location. The sound from the track isn't any different than a combine or tractor running in the fields for hours on end. Sometimes I think some people move out here in the country would like to get rid of us farmers too. Maybe we bother their sense of utopia? Bring on the track. It will help bring business to the county, and help reduce my property tax. "

Tvrdy gets it wrong wrote on November 26, 2006 7:01 pm:
" That wildlife land is farther up the highway, isn't it? Highway 77 is paved isn't it? The parking you mention is the paved parking. There is overflow parking on site to allow thousands of cars. Just look at the plans on file at the county. If you are going to express your opinion, I suggest you research a little better. You ignorance is showing. Stop the Lies, Theresa. You shold be ashamed. "

Jarhead wrote on November 26, 2006 7:14 pm:
" So Larry I can assume from your letter that you are in favor of leaving Iraq immediately? You know just prior to the 2002 misterm elections MANY democrats claimed the same reasons for removing Hussain from power as the administration. I guess it only matters when a republican president is calling the shots. Why didn't any of those dmeocrats who voted in favor of invading Iraq speak up about the administrations "miscalculations" at the time? Did they vote for the war KNOWING that it would end in failure so they could win back the majority as they have now done? Interesting observations Larry. "

Build the racetrack wrote on November 26, 2006 7:36 pm:
" The benefits to the entire county are hard to overlook. Mr. Sanford ran a nice race track. I liked racing there. The decision to move it to a better location is a logical choice. As a Lincoln resident, I look forward to the benefits to the great majority of us. There will be increased business brought to our area from racers all over the midwest. I have talked to many people that live up in that area that want the race track there. I don't think an inconvience for a few should limit the entire county. There is too much of that going on in our county that limits our economic growth. "

If LJS is campaigning for the left... wrote on November 26, 2006 7:45 pm:
" Then I am not living in the same dimension as you are P. Robert. Are you joking, do you see who they endorse every election year, there's not a liberal name or value on the list. If you can legitimately back your opinion up with fact, I am very open to hear it because I would like to be able see what you are seeing that I seem to be missing. "

Bring on NHRA Racing wrote on November 26, 2006 8:21 pm:
" The site north of Lincoln has almost 160 acres. Denver has a similar track that holds national events on 115 acres. The dragstrip part of the facility at Atlanta, Gainesvill, Houston, Joliet, etc. is about the same size or smaller. The new drag strip here at Lincoln can eventually handle large events such as divisional meets or national meets. As a resident, I would love to have events that bring in 10,000 or 20,000 or 50,000 people to see the big events that those other cities enjoy. Our hotels and restaraunts would be full. The sales tax and hotel tax collections would help the current budget and tax issues. Brainerd, MN brings in $10,000,000 in economic impact from their NHRA national event. Gainesville, FL brings in more sales tax dollars from ONE national event than for SEVEN Florida Gators HOME FOOTBALL GAMES! That should ring a bell in this town. Plus the extra economic impact to increase sales in local businesses to pay for jobs. And it isn't the government taking our taxes to build economic growth. It is a good thing when a local person wants to invest in our community. Thank you Mr. Sanford. "

Carol Brown wrote on November 26, 2006 9:39 pm:
" I agree with Joe the facts in this letter were way off base. My son is a student at UNL in Agricultural Engineering and he has records of the sound levels of agricultural equipment used and it is way over the top of the sound levels we are discussing for the race track. All this negative talk is a chicken little syndrome. It will not be as intrusive as you are saying. This corridor is ripe for development as is all of Lancaster County along major routes of travel. It is a sign of the times and we should be thankful for this progression because we need the revenue and the jobs or we will be paying with our pocketbooks in an increasing rate and have no places of employment for our growing population. "

Old Racer Sam wrote on November 26, 2006 10:50 pm:
" Dodge County never came through. I remember racing at Scribner back in the early 1980's and we had to have a tractor there to help pull the cars up the hill after a rain. The road was in such bad condition. We all had expensive race cars and trailers, and the county wouldn't even put gravel down. They practically had to be begged to get gravel on the county road. Later they promised to pave the road, but never came through. Then they said they would. But later changed it to say they could only do half. After all the business that it brought to the Fremont hotels, etc. There were divisional NHRA events, and National IHRA events. The track was too far off the beaten path. To improve the opportunity the track needed to be closer to Omaha or Lincoln. Now that opportunity has come. Thanks. Let's not let this pass us by. This can bring thousands of visitors to Lincoln every spring, summer and fall. More than all the university sports combined. Bring on the Drag Races!!! "

jeff wrote on November 27, 2006 9:58 am:
" its truly amazing to watch the people against this extort small details as a reason to be against the track. In referrence to the parking spaces did you ever think about shuttling people in from places in town? No you didnt because the cprlife people have sucked you into their fear based campaign instead of opening your eyes to the facts. Hmm sounds familiar huh? "

KellyJo wrote on November 27, 2006 1:32 pm:
" I'm not a racing fan, so I most likely wouldn't frequent any type of racing event. However, I do think that the revenue generated can only be good for Lincoln and Lancaster county. For all you naysayers, be careful. If you think that Omaha isn't paying attention to all of this, then you're wrong. I predict that all the whining and crying around here will drive this opportunity right up the road to Omaha. Omaha will reap the benefits and Lincoln will (pun intended) be left in the dust. "

Ann wrote on November 27, 2006 4:03 pm:
" Major difference between seasonal farm noise and weekly Friday to Sunday racetrack noise. I moved into a farming community and accept the seasonal farming noise. I would never move within a 5 mile range of a racetrack and don't want it moving into our area. By the way, the local farmer harvesting 500 feet from my home registers @ 65 decibels. Sanford's attorney whined that 65 decibels within a mile of the track is not feasible. Go try Omaha. If we used Omaha zoning law, this wouldn't even be discussed since they don't allow racetracks in AG land and quickly turned one down last year. No one wants the noise. "

OIF vet wrote on November 27, 2006 4:18 pm:
" Great point CS. My unit deployed with a full mess section, as did most, if not all, of the units we were stationed with. KBR took over the dining facilities and we kept those soldiers in country, for no reason at all, and continue to deploy soldiers that are not used while paying KBR to take care of those duties. "

Larry McClung wrote on November 27, 2006 7:36 pm:
" Jarhead - Your assumption that I'm in favor of pulling out of Iraq immediately is just that, an assumption. What I'm in favor of is holding this administration accountable for its actions, just as I was in favor of holding the Johnson and Nixon administrations accountable for theirs. While I agree time should be spent in thoughtful consideration as to how to get out of Bush's war in Iraq, I'm more interested in not forgetting how we got in Bush's war in Iraq. Otherwise, thirty years from now, we'll be having this same exchange. "

Phil wrote on November 28, 2006 8:46 pm:
" I panegyrize Larry McClung’s pretentious partisan screed apropos Roger Conrad’s partisan bleat. I spent most of Sunday morning on ‘dictionary.com’ trying to limn McClung’s billet! McClung cert manifests the referenced cerebration sonorously with a substratum much less puerile than a Petri dish. I’d like to consider myself an educated person. However, “screed”, “bleat”, “paean”, “hectoring”.... are you kidding me? Regardless of McClung’s political views, if McClung’s inner circle talks like this, please tell me where they hang out so I don’t forget my dictionary. "